The Issue of Authority in Eastern Orthodox Tradition: A Protestant View

Victor SHLENKIN

Abstract


The concept of “Tradition” in Orthodox theology evokes curious and ambiguous associations in the minds of evangelical Christians. Sometimes Protestants conceive of Tradition as something parallel to the Bible, as a sort of collection of ancient texts and rules. Quite probably that is the assumption of popular Orthodox theology as well. However, in our research we wish to reveal Tradition as it is regarded by academic authors who represent the classical Orthodox witness.
What is the nature of Tradition? Does it have a textual basis? Who has the right to express and explain it, applying Tradition to the settling of many issues of church life? How practical is their reasoning? These are a few of the questions raised in the article. By examining the works of recognized Orthodox theologians and presenting to them critical questions connected with the actual embodiment of theological discourse concerning Tradition in the church life of Orthodox Christians, we hope to understand more deeply the basis of our own traditional Protestant faith, which is rooted completely in the study of Holy Scripture.

Keywords


Concept of “Tradition” in Orthodox theology; Eastern Orthodox Tradition; theological discourse concerning Tradition in the church life of Orthodox Christians

Full Text:

PDF

References


Russian sources:

Adel’geim, Pavel. Dogmat o tserkvi v kanonakh i praktike (Dogma concerning the Church in canons and practice). Second enlarged edition. Pskov, 2002.

_____________. Interv’iu: Protoirei Pavel Adel’geim: “Moia sud’ba v kakoi-to mere povtoriaet sud’bu afkhepiskopa Ermogena (Golubeva), tol’ko vremia togda bylo drugoe” (Interview: Protopriest Pavel Adel’geim: “My destiny somehow repeats the destiny of archbishop Hermogen (Golubev), only the times were different). Portal Credo, 2002. 8 April 2008. http://portal-credo.ru/site/?act=news&id=61772 (8 April 2008).

Bulgakov, Sergei. Pravoslavie (Orthodoxy). Moscow: АСТ, 2003.

Evdokimov, Pavel. Pravoslavie (Orthodoxy). Moscow: Bible Institute of St. Andrew, 2002.

Fairbairn, Donald. Inymi glazami: Vzgliad evangel’skogo khristianina na Vostochnoe Pravoslavie (Eastern Orthodoxy through Western eyes). Rovno: Format A, 2003.

Kallistos, Bishop (Ware). Pravoslavnaia tserkov’ (The Orthodox Church). Moscow: Bible Institute of St. Andrew, 2001.

____________. “Bogoslovskoe obrazovanie v Pisanii i u sv. Otsov” (Theological education in the Scriptures and in the holy Fathers). Biblioteka Iakova Krotova. September 1998.

http://www.krotov.infohistory20krivovaware11.html (1 June 2004).

____________. “Strannaia i vse zhe blizkaia” (Strange yet familiar: My journey to the Orthodox Church.” Biblioteka Iakova Krotova. September 1998.

http://www.krotov.infohistory20krivovaware14.html (1 June 2004).

Losskiy, Vladimir. “Ocherki misticheskogo bogosloviia Vostochnoi Tserkvi” (Essays on the mystical theology of the Eastern Church). In Bogovidenie (God’s vision). Moscow: АСТ, 2003.

Meyendorff, John. “Est’ li v tserkvi vneshniy avtoritet? Istoricheskiy relativism i avtoritet v khristianskom verouchenii (Is there external authority in the church? Historical relativism and authority in Christian teaching). In Pravoslavie v sovremennom mire (Orthodoxy in the modern world). Klin: Fond «Khristianskaia Zhizn’», 2002.

Portal-credo: Upravliaiushchiy Surozhskoi eparkhii RPTs MP prosit Patriarkha Moskovskogo otpustit’ ego v Konstantinopol’skuiu iurisdiktsiiu (Head of Surozh Diocese of the Russian Orthodox Church asks the patriarch of Moscow to release him to the jurisdiction of Constantinople), Portal CREDO, 2002. http://portal-credo.ru/site/?act=news&id=42829&cf= (9 May 2006).

____________. “ ‘Novye russkie’ v Surozhskoi eparkhii vospriniali londonskiy Uspenskiy Sobor kak klub po interesam, utverzhdaet odna iz starykh prikhozhanok” (“New Russians” in Sourozh diocese treat London’s Uspenskiy Cathedral as a special interest club, says one of its old parishioners), Portal CREDO, 2002. http://portal-credo.ru/site/?act=news&id=43982&cf= (8 June 2006).

English sources:

Campenhausen, Hans von. The Fathers of the Church. Peabody, Mass.: Hendrickson Publishers, 2000.

Coniaris, Anthony. Introducing the Orthodox Church. Minneapolis, Minn.: Light and Life Publishing Company, 1982.

Florovsky, George. “The Authority of Ancient Councils and the Tradition of the Fathers.” In Eastern Orthodox Theology: A Contemporary Reader, ed. Daniel B. Clendenin, 115-124. Grand Rapids, Mich.: Baker Book House.

Hopko, Thomas. “Criteria of Truth in Orthodox Theology.” St Vladimir’s Seminary Quarterly XV (1971): 121-129.

Meyendorff, John. Catholicity and the Church. New York: STSP, 1983.

____________. Living Tradition: Orthodox Witness in the Contemporary World. Crestwood, N.Y.: St Vladimir’s Seminary Press, 1978.

____________.“One Bishop in One City.” St Vladimir’s Seminary Quarterly V (1961): 54-62.

O'Keefe, John J. and R. R. Reno. Sanctified Vision: An Introduction to Early Christian Interpretation of the Bible. Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press, 2005.

Osborn, Eric. Irenaeus of Lyons. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2001.

Ramsey, Boniface. Beginning to Read the Fathers. New York: Paulist Press, 1985.

Schmemann, Alexander. “Moment of Truth in Orthodoxy.” In Eastern Orthodox Theology: A Contemporary Reader, ed. Daniel B. Clendenin, 203-210. Grand Rapids, Mich.: Baker Book House.

Zizioulas, John D. Being as Communion: Studies in Personhood and the Church. Crestwood, N.Y.: St. Vladimir’s Seminary Press, 1985.




Copyright (c) 2017 Victor SHLENKIN

THEOLOGICAL REFLECTIONS: EURO-ASIAN JOURNAL OF THEOLOGY

ISSN 2521-179X (Online), ISSN 2415-783X (Print)